When you vacation on Marco Island, you’re going for the beauty of Florida’s Paradise Coast. From its pristine waters to beautiful sandy beaches, there’s no wonder why it’s a getaway hotspot. But there’s more to Marco Island than its waterfront! Don’t miss out on the best restaurants in Marco Island offering the freshest food on the coast. While you’re vacationing at one of our lovely Marco Island Rentals, feel free to check out the restaurants listed below:
Food Culture On Marco Island
If you’re a local, you’re aware of the popular food culture among the restaurants in Marco Island. For visitors, you’ll discover the beauty of the island with delicious food to match. Nearly every kind of dining experience is possible, especially seafood.
For foodies looking for their next unforgettable meal, these Marco Island restaurants have everything covered. If you love fish, wine, and fine dining, you must check these places out!
Popular Marco Island Restaurants
We’ve compiled the best of the best restaurants for your Marco Island dining experience. Every one of these foodie hotspots is about half an hour’s drive away from our Marco Island rentals, so a bite to eat isn’t far away from your beautiful stay!
The Oyster Society
In the heart of Marco Island, you’ll find the popular seafood joint named The Oyster Society. This seafood and raw bar strives to offer visitors the freshest hand-selected seafood caught locally. You’ll find everything from fish to shellfish to daily raw bar specials! Discover The Oyster Society’s exquisite wine collection and beautifully crafted cocktails that perfectly complement any item on the menu. Check out the raw bar menu which offers their seasonal oyster and clams dish, fresh-caught jumbo wild shrimp, baked oyster trio, and the Oceanic platter.
Test your tastebuds with unique dishes like the Caramelized Spanish Octopus, New Orleans Hot Pot, and Yuzu-Scented Tune Tartare. You won’t find meals like these just anywhere, so take a chance and try something completely new! From The Oyster Society’s regular selections and specials to its extensive menu of local seafood and wine, this restaurant is a must on your vacation checklist.
DaVinci’s
For another highly selected restaurant, you’ll find one of the finest dining experiences available at DaVinci’s. Known for its authentic Italian roots, DaVinci’s offers excellent service and cooks with the freshest ingredients for their menu items. If you’re looking for Mediterranean dishes, this is the perfect spot for you! Order classic Italian meals like fresh pasta made daily including specialty ravioli, spaghetti, gnocchi, lasagna, and risotto. Try the Ravioli di Mare stuffed with Maine lobster and topped with seared sea scallops for the perfect seafood and pasta combination!
Check out the Chef Specialities that include Zuppa di Pesce with white shrimp, mussels, Florida Middleneck clams, Calamari, and marinara sauce on crostini or linguine pasta. Try the Vitello DaVinci with thinly pounded veal, prosciutto, tomatoes, basil, mozzarella, and a light tomato sauce. Refresh with a wide selection of cocktails and fine wines that will help you cool off and relax on the beautiful Florida coast. You’ll find anything from reds, whites, champagne, and sparking wines along with plenty of draft beers.
Fin Bistro
Discover one of the best fresh fish restaurants on Marco Island at Fin Bistro. Offering guests fine dining service and a vibrant, relaxed island feel, you can enjoy a signature cocktail or unique wines with your fresh-caught meal.
You’ll find fresh local and regional fish and shellfish with dinner specials like Panko Herb Crusted Yellowtail Snapper with shrimp, risotto, coconut brown butter sauce, and herb sprouts. Try other favorites like Maple Bourbon Glazed Scottish Salmon, Sauteed Florida Keys Dorado, or Seared Florida Black Grouper. Fin Bistro also has a fantastic selection of local meats, produce, and dairy. Try their Grilled Beef Filet Mignon, Miso Marinated Portobello, or Wagyu Burger. Finish up your meal with a delicious dessert like White Chocolate Apple Croissant Bread Pudding, Key Lime Flan, or Dark Chocolate Truffle Cake.
Cocomo’s Grill
At Town Center Plaza on Marco Island, you’ll find Cocomo’s Grill serving the best food around. From seafood to steaks, pasta to salads, and sandwiches to falafel, there’s something for everyone at this casual yet refined restaurant. Their servers ensure the best service possible, with their knowledge, passion, and friendly attitudes that keep guests coming back. When you go to Cocomo’s Grill, you’re another part of their family! When you visit Cocomo’s Grill, you must try their house specialty Seared Ahi Tuna Nachos. A delicious twist on this classic comfort food, it includes Sushi grade Ahi Tuna sprinkled with sesame seeds, ginger root, and black pepper. Seared rare and cut into delectable cubes, the tuna is served over a seaweed salad and wonton chips drizzled with wasabi mayo and sesame garlic sauce.
For a twist on shellfish, try the delicious and unique Drunken Shrimp. Marinated in dark beer and Old Bay seasoning, this peel-and-eat shrimp is then steamed with garlic. Enjoy it hot with cocktail sauce!
The Boulevard
Last but not least, we’re finishing this list with one of the best Marco Island restaurants operated by a local family. With over two decades of restaurant experience, Chef Edgar began his restaurant career at 15 years old and continues to deliver high-quality food today.
The friendly staff at The Boulevard strives to bring guests a memorable restaurant experience. Check out their menu items including pasta, meats, seafood, and salads. With the wide variety available, everyone will find their next favorite dish! Try the Rigatoni Calabrese stuffed with pancetta bacon, asparagus, shallots, tomatoes, roasted garlic, cream, and Reggiano cheese. Guests with gluten intolerance can enjoy the gluten-free Primavera sauteed with olive oil and garlic with a side of seasonal vegetables.
For fresh seafood, try something unique with the Frutti di Mare with clams, calamari, mussels, and other seafood sauteed in marinara sauce over spaghetti. Another great option is the Barramundi Almondine with Barramundi sauteed in olive oil and topped with roasted almonds. With a twist of citrus sauce, mashed potatoes, and broccoli, it’s an unforgettable meal!
Plan Your Next Visit!
Your new favorite restaurant is waiting for you on Marco Island! Browse our wide selection of vacation properties and start planning your next culinary adventure today!
Book Your Marco Island Rentals With Clausen Properties
The next time you’re looking for a fantastic vacation spot, look no further than our Marco Island home rentals! Whether you’re booking a family vacation or a solo getaway, our rentals are the perfect balance between a hotel and a condo.
Offering rentals with two, three, four, and five-bedroom accommodations, with private spaces and communal areas, our rentals make you feel right at home. Our rentals come with fully-equipped kitchens, beautiful interiors, spacious rooms, private pools, bar seating, an open deck with a grill, and more. Indoors, our rentals offer at least one master bedroom with gorgeous waterfront views that you get to wake up to every morning. Every room comes with beautiful furnishings, large closets, and TVs for entertainment after winding down from the day. Our rentals also have walk-in showers, poolside entrances, a patio, and the most comfortable sofas you’ve ever sat on.
Our rentals are within easy access to the local beaches, restaurants, shops, and attractions like museums. Never be far from the fun of downtown and soaking in as much sun as your heart desires! However, if you’re looking for a condo, we’re glad to inform you that we offer top-notch Marco Island condo rentals. No matter what living space you’re picturing for your island adventure, we deliver! When you’re ready for an unforgettable vacation, find your happy place on Marco Island. Book a call with us today to get your beach day started!