When you’re soaking in the sun on Marco Island, there’s nothing quite as refreshing as a scoop—or three—of ice cream to cool you down. With its pristine beaches, lush natural surroundings, and vibrant local culture, Marco Island is a paradise for vacationers.
What better way to complement your stay in one of our luxurious Marco Island rental homes than indulging in some delicious Marco Island ice cream?
Whether you’re a local or a traveler looking for fun things to do in Marco Island with kids, a visit to its best ice cream spots is a must.
About Marco Island
Marco Island has been a popular destination for thousands of years, firstly inhabited by the Calusa and their Muspa ancestors. The Key Marco Cat, a significant artifact from this period, highlights the island’s rich Native American heritage. Modern development began in 1870 with Captain W. D. “Bill” Collier establishing the clamming and fishing industries. Increased connectivity in the 1920s and transformative real estate projects by the Mackle brothers in the mid-20th century furthered the island’s growth. Situated just south of Naples on Florida’s Southwest Coast, Marco Island blends luxury and nature, offering access to the Gulf of Mexico and the Ten Thousand Islands. The island is a family-friendly destination with diverse activities, including beachcombing, yoga, kayaking, eco-tours, and fishing. Visitors can enjoy fresh seafood, local art, unique shopping experiences, and a range of accommodations from luxury resorts to camping at Collier-Seminole State Park. Marco Island stands out as a tropical oasis combining historical significance and modern amenities.
Mr. Bentley’s Homemade Ice Cream
If you’re on the hunt for the best Marco Island ice cream, look no further than Mr. Bentley’s Homemade Ice Cream. Known as Marco Island’s only craft ice cream parlor, Mr. Bentley’s prides itself on offering all-natural ice cream with 17% butterfat, making their scoops incredibly rich and creamy. Unlike commercial ice creams, they use natural ingredients for everything, even employing beet juice instead of artificial red dye 40 for coloring. Their ice cream is crafted the old-fashioned way, honoring traditional methods to deliver an authentically flavorful experience. Whether you’re a fan of classic options or are eager to try some of their seasonal flavors, Mr. Bentley’s has something for everyone. With a wide variety of your favorite ice creams, a visit to one of their Marco Island locations is a must for any ice cream lover.
Sweet Annie’s
Sweet Annie’s, a locally owned and operated ice cream shop, is one of the original and most cherished establishments on Marco Island. This charming parlor has been serving delightful frozen treats for years, becoming a beloved staple for both locals and visitors. Whether you visit after a day at the beach, post-dinner, or following a bike ride, Sweet Annie’s promises a nostalgic sweet spot that enhances your Marco Island experience. What makes Sweet Annie’s truly special is its curated experience. Beyond their delicious hand-scooped ice cream, you can indulge in the island’s largest selection of vintage candy, retro sodas, puzzles, and novelties. For those who want to bring a piece of this magical place home, Sweet Annie’s offers pints, ice cream pies, and bulk candy. Their recently added bulk candy wall allows you to select your favorites and purchase by the pound, making it one of the best activities on Marco Island for kids, who can create their own box of sweet memories.
Beebee’s Ice Cream
Beebee’s Ice Cream, a beloved local establishment, offers homemade ice cream in an astounding variety of 36 flavors, including three fat-free, sugar-free options and three fat-free yogurts. Catering to both classic flavor enthusiasts and those with dietary preferences, Beebee’s has something for everyone. Visitors can enjoy their ice cream in a variety of cones or cups or choose to elevate their experience with sundaes, milkshakes, or ice cream sodas. The shop also serves shaved ice, smoothies, iced coffees, regular coffee, sodas, and water. Adding a personal touch, Beebee’s offers an assortment of retro and modern candies, as well as gourmet candy. To complete the experience, you can shop for personalized souvenirs and plush toys, making it a perfect stop for creating lasting memories with your family. Considering its diverse offerings, Beebee’s is a must-visit when looking for the best ice cream in Marco Island.
Dulce Mare
Dulce Mare offers an elevated take on the typical ice cream parlor, focusing on creating luxurious and mouth-watering treats. Started by owners passionate about sweets and confectionery, Dulce Mare turns every scoop and every bite into a work of art. The shop provides a delicious selection of gelato churned and frozen to perfection, handcrafted candy, toffee, popcorn, macaroons, and bark. What sets Dulce Mare apart is its genuine attention to detail and craftsmanship, making it a fantastic spot not only for ice cream but also for a broader selection of sugary delights. If you have a sophisticated palate or simply want to try something unique, this is your go-to spot in Marco Island.
Plan Your Next Visit!
Are you ready to start planning your next adventure on Marco Island? Browse our entire selection of properties today and find the perfect match for your stay!
Book Your Marco Island Rental With Clausen Properties
When you plan your visit to Marco Island, make sure you check out the various Marco Island condos, especially those close to these ice cream havens. Having one of these rentals on Marco Island nearby is extremely convenient after a long day of sunbathing or exploring. Clausen Properties offers vacation rentals that cater to diverse needs and preferences, ensuring a comfortable and memorable stay. Our accommodations come with a range of amenities, including fully equipped kitchens, spacious living areas, private balconies with stunning views, and access to swimming pools and fitness centers. Some rentals even offer direct beach access and outdoor grilling areas, perfect for family gatherings. These accommodations place you in close proximity to some of the best things to do in Marco Island and the best ice cream shops on Marco Island, as well as other must-visit local attractions. For hassle-free planning and to maximize your enjoyment of all that this beautiful destination has to offer, make sure to book your Marco Island rental with Clausen Properties.